Fresh Juice Reality Check: Store Bottles vs Juice Bars vs Stein Co. Sips

Fresh Juice Reality Check: Store Bottles vs Juice Bars vs Stein Co. Sips
(aka why our $24–$26 for 64 oz of real juice isn’t crazy)

 

Let's just stick to orange juice for the simplicity of the example.


Grocery Store / Whole Foods (Suja, Evolution, 365, etc.)
Typical Juice Bar (16 oz bottle or takeaway)
Stein Co. Sips (pickup/delivery only)
Size you get
12–16 oz
12–16 oz
64 oz (a full half-gallon!)
Price you pay
$5.99 – $9.99
$9 – $14
$24 – $26
Price per ounce
$0.50 – $0.75
$0.70 – $1.00+
$0.38 – $0.41
What’s inside
Cold-pressed → pasteurized or HPP → shipped across the country → sometimes 6–12 months old by the time you drink it → often “natural flavors” or citric acid added back in
Fresh that day → but you pay for the $80K press, rent, staff, and the cute branding
Literally squeezed or juiced in my kitchen the same week you pick it up. Zero additives, zero pasteurization, zero middlemen. Just fruit, water + love.
How many oranges
6–8 in a 12-oz bottle (they stretch it)
10–14 in a 16-oz (generous bars)
21+ real oranges in every 64-oz Orange Juice
Convenience
Grab and go from fridge
Drive to the shop, wait in line
Text me → I bring it to your porch or you swing by
Who makes money
Giant factory → distributor → Whole Foods → you
Shop owner barely breaks even after rent
100 % stays with a local human (me) who’s trying to pay rent and keep doing this
The Math Everyone Forgets
  • Whole Foods 12-oz organic orange juice = $6.99 → $0.58/oz
    → To get a full 64 oz you’d need more than five bottles = $37+
  • Juice bar 16-oz fresh orange = $11–$13 → 64 oz would be $44–$52 if they even sold that size (they don’t)
Meanwhile you hand me $24–$26 and walk away with a half-gallon mason jar packed with 21+ oranges, squeezed fresh, no heat, no preservatives, no plastic bottle.It’s not “expensive.”

It’s honestly the best deal in town if you actually want real, living juice instead of fancy, sugar, fruit flavored water.

Grab a 64-oz Sunshine Orange or Crisp Apple this week and taste the difference yourself. Your taste buds (and wallet, once you do the math) will thank you.